The NutriTrade project has developed innovative and cost-efficient measures that reduce the eutrophication of the Baltic Sea. Within the project, four new ways to reduce eutrophication were piloted: cyprinid fishing, treating cultivated fields with gypsum, nutrient cycling, and mussel farming. The project also created a crowdfunding platform, nutribute.org, that targets waterway protection.
In 2015-2018 NutriTrade, a flagship project of the EU Baltic Sea strategy, successfully implemented the Saving the sea objective of the strategy. The project reached the following conclusions and results:
The project developed new and cost-efficient measures that reduce the eutrophication of the Baltic Sea. The cost of a kg of phosphorus, removed through the gypsum treatment of fields and cyprinid fishing, was approximately €70. Removing nutrients in the form of mussels, however, turned out to be more expensive (€670/kg of P).
Recycling nutrients amongst various fields of industry was recognised as a measure that boosts Baltic Sea protection and nutrient utilisation. Nutrients created in biogas production, for example, can be utilised by the forest industry. This could potentially mean several hundreds of tonnes of phosphorus each year in the Baltic Sea region.
Information on the most successful measures was disseminated to e.g. the Baltic Sea protection commission HELCOM, and to states in the Baltic Sea area. Moreover, policy recommendations released by the project encouraged the launch of extensive gypsum treatment of fields, and proposed the further development of environmental protection steering methods, allowing new measures to be adopted.
Nutribute.org, created within the NutriTrade project, is the first European crowdfunding platform that targets waterway protection. The Ålandsbanken Baltic Sea Project selected Nutribute as the best digital innovation of 2018. The platform is named Nutribute, a combination of nutrients and contribute, which here signifies both participation and making a donation.
Through the crowdfunding platform, NutriTrade encouraged private individuals and corporations to estimate their nutrient discharges, to reduce them, and to compensate for the remaining discharges with a donation to a waterway protection project of their choice. Finnish water utilities were the first ones to latch on to the idea of nutrient discharge compensation. With donations from water utilities, Helsinki, Kotka, Turku and Porvoo became phosphorus-neutral cities as far as their wastewater discharges were concerned.
Nutribute enables the implementation of waterway protection projects, adds to their impact, and continues their work even after the project itself has ended.
The NutriTrade project achieved considerable results in waterway protection. With the project’s pilot measures, the phosphorus load of the Baltic Sea by was reduced by six tonnes in the years 2015-2018, and for most of the measures, discharge reduction will continue also in the future. Moreover, measures funded via the Nutribute platform reduced the phosphorus load by 28 tonnes. A reduction of a total of 34 tonnes of phosphorus equals the annual wastewater discharges of a major city.
The NutriTrade project ended in early 2019. The project’s main funder was the EU Interreg Central Baltic programme, and it was implemented by the John Nurminen Foundation, the University of Helsinki, the Natural Resources Institute Finland, SLU, and Anthesis Enveco.
Project website www.nutritradebaltic.eu
‘Nutrient discharge trading can reduce the costs of the reductions we aim for locally, nationally and internationally. By designing trading models that encourage the development of new and innovative nutrient reduction measures we create new opportunities for bringing the Baltic Sea ecosystem back to health.’
– Katarina Elofsson, Associate Professor, Swedish University of Agricultural Sciences
‘Utilising its expertise, the Natural Resources Institute of Finland seeks to support the development and deployment of smart environmental steering methods. In this project, we are responsible for surveying the financial and institutional ecosystem of the Baltic Sea, which will accommodate these flexible steering mechanisms. We will support the project with our research history and our cooperation networks. When flexible mechanisms are being planned on the Baltic level, it is worthwhile to learn from existing nutrient trading systems elsewhere in the world. Participating from the Natural Resources Institute are researchers Antti Iho and Lassi Ahlvik, who have previously studied the application of flexible mechanisms to environmental questions and, amongst other things, compared protection institutions in the Baltic Sea area and in the US.
From the viewpoint of the researchers, the project is a unique opportunity to promote and boost the efficiency of water protection in the Baltic Sea area. The mechanism that will be built in the project will enable protective measures that would be laborious to implement with public funding. In the best case scenario, the project will encourage citizens to protect the waters they love, and to act as forerunners for environmental protection implemented with public funding.’
– Antti Iho, Principal Research Scientist, Natural Resources Institute of Finland